The 10 Most Underrated College Football Players of All Time

Getty Images

Part of the fun of college football is its sheer breadth. There are over 120 teams that compete in the FBS, which means that storylines and hidden superstars abound. Naturally, it also guarantees that some of the best players in the country get overshadowed and forgotten in the sport's warp-speed news cycle. Here are ten of the most underrated college football players of all time.

BJ Symons, Texas Tech

GettyImages 110333313
Getty Images
  • Position: Quarterback
  • Born: November 19th, 1980 (Houston, Texas)
  • High School: Cypress Creek (Houston, Texas)
  • NFL Draft: 2004 / Round: 7 / Pick: 248
  • NFL Career: Houston Texans (2004), Chicago Bears (2006)
  • Career Highlights: Sammy Baugh Trophy (2003), Second-team All-Big 12 (2003), 10th in Heisman voting (2003), NCAA record for single-season passing yards (5,833)

BJ Symons is the posterboy for the transformative powers of the Air Raid offensive system popularized by Mike Leach. After serving as Texas Tech’s backup for his first two years, Symons exploded in 2003 once he was elevated to the starting job. In his first and only year as Tech’s starter, Symons tossed for a record-setting 5,833 yards (since surpassed by Bailey Zappe in 2021) and 52 touchdowns, which at the time was second highest single season total of all time. Despite his historic productivity, Symons was never really appreciated, finishing 10th in Heisman voting and going 248th in the NFL Draft that spring; he never played in an NFL game.

Graham Harrell, Texas tech

GettyImages 83751131
Getty Images
  • Position: Quarterback
  • Born: May 22nd, 1985 (Brownwood, Texas)
  • High School: Ennis High School (Ennis, Texas)
  • NFL Draft: Undrafted (2009)
  • NFL Career: Green Bay Packers (2010-2012), New York Jets (2013)
  • Career Highlights: Sammy Baugh Trophy (2007), Johnny Unitas Golden Arm Award (2008), second-team All-Big 12 (2007), Super Bowl champion (XLV)

Another product of Mike Leach’s assembly line of prolific quarterbacks, Graham Harrell might’ve been Leach’s best. Forming one of the best quarterback-receiver batteries with star wide receiver Michael Crabtree, Harrell became the first quarterback in college football history to rack up multiple 5,000 yard seasons. Although Harrell was overshadowed at the time by conference-mates Sam Bradford and Colt McCoy, he might’ve been the best of the trio setting a since-broken NCAA record of 134 touchdown passes. Despite his collegiate brilliance, Harrell went undrafted in 2009 and threw for a grand total of 20 yards in the NFL, but did manage to win a Super Bowl in 2010 as Aaron Rodgers’s backup.

Keenan Reynolds, Navy

GettyImages 501132010
Getty Images
  • Position: Quarterback
  • Born: December 13th, 1994 (Antioch, Tennessee)
  • High School: Goodpasture Christian School (Madison, Tennessee)
  • NFL Draft: 2016 / Round: 6 / Pick: 182
  • NFL Career: Baltimore Ravens (2016), Washington Redskins (2017), Seattle Seahawks (2018)
  • Career Highlights: AAC Offensive Player of the Year (2015), First-team All-ACC (2015), Third-team All-American (2015), James E. Sullivan Award (2015)

The triple-option is perhaps the oldest offensive play in football, but nobody has ever run it better than Keenan Reynolds. During his four year tenure at Navy, Reynolds did most of his damage on the ground as the point-man of Navy’s rushing attack. By doing so, he amassed 4,559 rushing yards and 88 rushing touchdowns, both of which are the most of any quarterback. Since Navy’s triple-option offense doesn’t require the quarterback to pass very much, Reynolds transitioned to wide receiver in the NFL Draft since he possessed NFL-caliber athleticism but not NFL-caliber passing ability. In 2018, he made his NFL debut, appearing in two games for Seattle but not registering any stats.

LenDale White, USC

GettyImages 121576091
Getty Images
  • Position: Running back
  • Born: December 20th, 1984 (Denver, Colorado)
  • High School: Chatfield (Littleton, Colorado)
  • NFL Draft: 2006 / Round: 2 / Pick: 45
  • NFL Career: Tennessee Titans (2006-2009), Seattle Seahawks (2010), Denver Broncos (2010)
  • Career Highlights: All-American (2005), National Champion (2005)

The mid-2000s USC teams are some of the most iconic college football teams in recent memory. Although Reggie Bush claimed most won the 2005 Heisman Trophy, LenDale White was the Trojans’ most consistently good running back. As the “thunder” half of USC’s vaunted Thunder and Lightning backfield, White set a school record with 24 touchdowns in 2005, Over the course of their overlapping three years in LA, White only rushed for 10 fewer yards than Bush (3,159 vs. 3169) but more than doubled Bush’s rushing touchdown total (52 vs. 25). In the NFL, White continued to be a bruising, physical runner and rushed for over 1,000 yards in 2007.

Jonathan Taylor, Wisconsin

GettyImages 1179286699
Getty Images
  • Position: Running back
  • Born: January 19th, 1999 (Salem, New Jersey)
  • High School: Salem (New Jersey)
  • NFL Draft: 2020 / Round: 2 / Pick: 41
  • NFL Career: Indianapolis Colts (2020-present)
  • Career Highlights: 3x Consensus All-Big Ten (2017-2019), 2x Unanimous All-American (2018, 2019), 2x Doak Walker Award (2018, 2019), PFWA All-Rookie Team (2020) FedEx Ground Player of the Year (2021), Bert Bell Award (2021), Pro Bowl (2021), First-team All-Pro (2021)

It’s weird to say that a player as celebrated as Jonathan Taylor could be one of the most underrated college football players of all time. Still, even his long resume undersells his dominance. In college, he earned the 6th most rushing yards in NCAA history despite declaring early for the NFL Draft and forgoing his senior season. He finished in the top ten of Heisman voting in all three years he played at Wisconsin and averaged well over 2,000 yards per season. As a result, Taylor was the best college running back of the last 25 years so it’s time to give him the recognition as such.

Peter Warrick, Florida State

GettyImages 453793804
Getty Images
  • Position: Wide receiver
  • Born: June 19th, 1977 (Bradenton, Florida)
  • High School: Southeast (Bradenton, Florida)
  • NFL Draft: 2000 / Round: 1 / Pick: 4
  • NFL Career: Cincinnati Bengals (2000-2004), Seattle Seahawks (2005)
  • Career Highlights: 3x First-team All-ACC (1997-1999), 2x Consensus All-American (1998, 1999), Sugar Bowl MVP (2000)

Warrick was a great player who put up great stats. But that’s almost beside the point. I mean, just watch these highlights. He was awesome.

Trevor Insley, Nevada

GettyImages 1573800
Getty Images
  • Position: Wide receiver
  • Born: December 25th, 1977 (San Clemente, California)
  • High School: San Clemente (San Clemente, California)
  • NFL Draft: 2000 / undrafted
  • NFL Career: Indianapolis Colts (2000)
  • Career highlights: 2x First-team All-Big West (1998, 1999), Second-team All-American (1999)

Statistically, Trevor Insley is probably the best wide receiver that college football has ever seen. In 1999, he earned 2,060 receiving yards,  an NCAA record that still stands nearly a quarter century later. When he graduated from Nevada in 2000, he did so with 5,005 receiving yards, which also a then-record in the NCAA (Corey Davis broke the record in 2016, bumping Insley down to 2nd on the career leaderboards). Surprisingly, Insley never really got much of an NFL opportunity, lasting only a single season on the Indianapolis Colts practice squad and never appearing in a game.

Elvis Dumervil, Louisville

GettyImages 51727446
Getty Images
  • Position: EDGE
  • Born: January 19, 1984 (Miami, Florida)
  • High School: Miami Jackson (Miami, Florida)
  • NFL Draft: 2006 / Round: 4 / Pick: 126
  • NFL Career: Denver Broncos (2006-2012), Baltimore Ravens (2013-2016), San Francisco 49ers (2017)
  • Career Highlights: Unanimous All-American (2005), Big East Defensive Player of the Year (2005), Ted Hendricks Award (2005), Bronko Nagurski Trophy (2005), 5x Pro Bowl (2009, 2011, 2012, 2014, 2015), 2x First-team All-Pro (2009, 2014)

Granted, sacks have only been tracked since 2005, but Dumervil’s 20.5 in his first and only season at Louisville are still tops in recent history. Moreover, he carried over that knack for bringing down the quarterback in the NFL, where he thrived with both the Denver Broncos and Baltimore Ravens.

Scooby Wright, Arizona

GettyImages 456467734
Getty Images
  • Position: Middle Linebacker
  • Born: August 28th, 1994 (Windsor, California)
  • High School: Cardinal Newman (Santa Rosa, California)
  • NFL Draft: 2016 / Round: 7 / Pick: 250
  • NFL Career: Cleveland Browns (2016), Arizona Cardinals (2016-2017), New England Patriots (2019) 
  • Career Highlights: Unanimous All-American (2014, Pac-12 Defensive Player of the Year (2014). First-team All-Pac 12 (2014). Bronko Nagurski Trophy (2014), Chuck Bednarik Award (2014)

Scooby Wright might be a one-season wonder, but that 2014 season was incredible. As a sophomore in 2014, Wright stuffed the stat sheet: 164 tackles, 31 tackles for loss, 15 sacks, five forced fumbles. Unfortunately, a combination of injuries and undersizedness prevented Wright from making his mark in the NFL.

Coby Bryant, Cincinnati

GettyImages 1236622745
Getty Images
  • Position: Cornerback 
  • Born: March 29th, 1999 (Cleveland, Ohio)
  • High School: Glenville (Cleveland, Ohio)
  • NFL Draft: 2022 / Round: 4 / Pick: 109
  • NFL Career: Seattle Seahawks (2022-present)
  • Career Highlights: Jim Thorpe Award (2021), First-team All-American (2021), 2x First team All-AAC (2020, 2021)

Coby Bryant may not have been quite as elite an NFL prospect as his teammate “Sauce” Gardner, but he was arguably even better in college. One of the defensive leaders on a loaded Cincinnati team that became the first Group of 5 school to make the College Football Playoffs, Bryant was the recipient of the Jim Thorpe Award, which is awarded to the best cornerback in the country.

Did you like this article?
Thumbs Up
Thumbs Down